2/4/10

Lloyd-Jones on Church History

"The modern man is very ignorant of history; he does not know that the hospitals originally came through the Church. It was Christian people who first, out of a sense of compassion for suffering and illness, began to do something about even physical diseases and illnesses. The first hospitals were founded by Christian people. The same thing is true of education; it was the Church that first saw this need and proceeded to do something about it. The same is true of Poor Law Relief and the mitigation of the sufferings of people who were enduring poverty. I argue that it is the Church that has really done this. Your trades unions and other such movements, you will find, if you go back to their beginnings, have almost invariably had Christian origins."

D. Martyn Lloyd-Jones, 1969

I found it interesting in this book on preaching by a Welshman that he comments on two major issues that we now consider to be the role of the government. Almost unthinkingly many Americans consider healthcare and education to be the role of the government. And not just any government: the federal government. I then began to wonder where most U.S. Senators got their degrees: from public universities or private ones? I then began to wonder about the U.S. Senate's healthcare plan, and how Americans pay for it. I haven't done this research, so someone could enlighten me here.

My point is that, implicitly, we all recognize that institutions with an investment in their own success do in fact do a better job fulfilling their purpose than institutions protected by government, which has no vested interest in its success.

Furthermore, Christian institutions have always done a better job at healthcare and education when removed from the influence of federal government. Let us not forget that the Establishment and Free Exercise (I refuse to say "separation of church and state" because the term has lost all meaning and has no Constitutional significance anyhow) of the 1st Amendment was written so that the government would stay out of influence in religious affairs.

That includes all areas of religious affairs, such as education and healthcare. Currently, states such as California have tried to outlaw homeschooling while the U.S. Senate plan will mandate that all Americans must buy health insurance.

So I've cloaked my argument in religious terms. I believe that these actions by the State are breaches of the first amendment, and thus my free exercise of religious belief. In short, these attempts by the government are unconstitutional. Besides, the Church, when unconstrained by the largesse of the Federal Government, does it better anyways.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

But the church and its agents also gave us the history pointed to in this very stark image.

www.dartmouth.edu/~spanmod/mural/panel13.html

The conquest continues--what do you think the invasion of Iraq was about?

And all of the horrors described on this site.

www.jesusneverexisted.com/cruelty.html

Plus why not Google: The Criminal History of the Papacy (Bushby)

David Strunk said...

Anonymous,

The Church universal (I'm not sure whether you mean the Catholic church but I'll use it in a more worldwide sense) is definitely guilty of atrocities. Part of the depravity of humanity is the very reason why Christianity's truth-claims make sense. That depravity does indeed extend to the Church.

But I hope you realize you didn't actually make any arguments in your comment.

The sky is pink.

Just because I said it doesn't make it true. And just because you post pictures doesn't make them compelling.

Atheism and it's secular counterparts in the 20th century were guilty of far greater human tragedies than the Christian church ever purported in 2000 years. Please see: communist Russia, communist China, Pol Pot in Cambodia, Idi Amin, naturlistic/social Darwinism in Nazi Germany, and many other examples.

And post your name next time. That's just plain gutless.